Shortcut Coconut Cream Pie

This post may contain affiliate links.  See my disclosure for more information.

Jump to recipe

This shortcut coconut cream pie proves that you can present a rich, amazing dessert using easy to find ingredients and almost no cooking.

Isn’t it terrible when you like something, but no one else in your family does?  Frequently, when we got to potlucks, or other events, I’ll make one of these recipes.

Coconut is one of those things around my house.

I looooovve coconut, but my family won’t eat it.  Weirdos.

So can you guess what I made for our church’s annual Harvest Supper dessert on Saturday?  Coconut cream pies of course.

Easy and Delicious Coconut Cream Pie

Who doesn’t love delicious?  But add in easy and WOW!

I am sure that a homemade custard would be outstanding in this.  And if you’ve got time to make one…more power to you.  But if you don’t, you can still present a rich, amazing dessert.

This pie uses instant pudding for the filling.  The key in getting a really thick and rich filling is in using less milk called for with the puddings.

I use vanilla pudding (I think I grabbed French Vanilla at the store for these).  The flavor of coconut flavored pudding is not my favorite.  And I also only use real whipped cream.  Cool-Whip makes me feel icky.  But as with any recipe, you use what you love!

The filling is packed with shreds of coconut.  Yum!

Crust

I have made it known before, but just in case you’ve missed it…I do not make pie crust from scratch.  If you prefer to make your own, by all means do!

Normally I would use Trader Joe’s pie crusts (they’re my fave), but for these I chose to use frozen pie crusts.  (I wanted to be able to leave the tins at church).

Pre-bake your crust and let it cool completely before filling it.

**Note** If you want this pie to be totally no-bake, it’s delicious with a shortbread cookie or graham cracker crust, too.

Toasting Coconut

The pie is topped with toasted coconut.  If you’re a coconut lover, you’re swooning with me at the thought of smelling toasting coconut, aren’t you?

It’s really easy to make.  The most difficult part is not forgetting it.  Burned coconut does not smell so great.  You can toast it either on the stovetop or in the oven.  I did mine on the stovetop and it was so fast!

I started it over medium heat, and then adjusted between medium and low while stirring pretty constantly.  It only took about 5 minutes.  Then just dump it on a towel or sheet of paper towel to cool.  Store any extra in a Ziploc bag.

Depending on the size of your pie shells, you may have extra filling.  (I had extra filling mixture that didn’t fit in my pie shells and have been snacking on that with a little toasted coconut sprinkled on top.)

Related Post:  The Only Pecan Pie That Matters

Are you thumbs up or thumbs down on coconut?